Logo Universität Bayreuth

"Exploring the Chemical Foundations of Other Worlds" 

Geologist Stephen Mojzsis brings an ERC Synergy Grant to Bayreuth to decode how stars and planets formed together — and what this reveals about Earth’s place in the galaxy.

Using a new combination of short videos and detailed online profiles, the University of Bayreuth will regularly shine a spotlight on the people behind its research. The goal is to increase the visibility of researchers and their work—and to further embed science communication in the public sphere. The video will be posted on the University of Bayreuth’s YouTube channel. The following interview was conducted by Gert-Dieter Meier (Press/Marketing/Communications, University of Bayreuth) with the researcher.

You’re coming to Bayreuth with an ERC Synergy Grant — a major award. What does it mean to you? 
In a nutshell, it truly is a labor of love. The idea behind this project began more than a dozen years ago, when I ran into a scientific wall in my overall research path. I had spent twenty five years searching for the world’s oldest rocks — and eventually we found one. It’s right here in the cabinet (he points to a glass display case in his office): a rock that is four billion years old. To put that into perspective, it has orbited the center of the galaxy seventeen times. One galactic year is about 225 million Earth years, so you can calculate your own galactic age if you like. I myself am a little over 35 galactic days old.

But once we found the oldest terrestrial rocks, I had to confront a problem: Earth is geologically active and we will likely not find a rock as old as the planet itself. Weathering, erosion, plate tectonics — everything gets recycled over the billions of years of our planet’s history. Meteorites, however, preserve material from the early solar system. Yet meteorites only tell us about our solar system. What about material from beyond it?

When I began thinking about this, we didn’t know of any interstellar visitors yet. Since then, we’ve had three: the asteroid like object ‘Oumuamua, the interstellar comet Borisov, and now Comet ATLAS. All three have orbits proving they cannot originate from our solar system. They are racing through it at enormous speeds — but we have no samples. So how can we know what planets around other stars are made of when we will never have direct samples of them owing to how far away they are?

This led me to some historical research. In 1802, the British geologist William Wollaston – inspired by his predeccessor Isaac Newton – passed focused sunlight through a prism, shown the rainbow on a white surface and noticed dark lines in the spectrum of colors. A decade later, the German glassmaker Joseph Frauenhofer read of the discovery of Mr. Wollastan and built an exceptionally large and flawless prism and identified about fifty such lines. He then had a remarkable insight: he compared the Sun’s spectrum to that of a fire, and then to the star Sirius. The lines for all three differed — meaning that they were not of the same kind. He didn’t know it at the time, but he had discovered stellar spectroscopy. (There is no evidence that the famous physicist and optician Joseph von Fraunhofer (1787–1826) ever visited Bayreuth. His life and work were primarily based in Munich and the Bavarian glassworks at Benediktbeuern, and he died at a young age in Munich.)

It wasn’t until the 1830s that the physical chemists Kirchhoff and Bunsen realized these lines correspond to specific elements present in the source of the light; these are known as absorption lines or Frauenhofer lines. By the late 19th century, scientists proposed that primitive meteorites are the leftover building blocks of planets. In 1927, Victor Moritz Goldschmidt suggested that the composition of such primitive meteorites – the building blocks of the planets – should match that of the Sun. This was confirmed forty years later, when high quality solar spectroscopy became available.

This means: If we know a star’s composition, we can use it to compute the composition of the building blocks of the planets that orbit the star.

This specific idea is the foundation of geoastronomy. And because the galaxy has evolved chemically over billions of years — through many stellar life cycles — we can also study how planetary building blocks have changed over cosmic time and thus modulate the kinds of planets that can form at any particular epoch in the history of our galaxy.

To understand this fully, we need a synergy of nuclear astrophysics, planetary geochemistry — my field — and experimental petrology. With this kind of scientific cooperation, we can plausibly propose the compositions of exoplanet building materials, recreate exotic non Earth like melts in the laboratory, and study the gases they produce. Atmospheric physicists can then search for these gases in exoplanet atmospheres using space telescopes.

That is geoastronomy: understanding the chemical foundations of rocky exoplanets.

You mentioned the ERC process was difficult. What happened? 
Our first ERC proposal was rejected outright — we didn’t even reach the interview stage! We received fourteen reviews. Imagine trying to convince fourteen scientists — trained skeptics — of anything. It’s nearly impossible, but this is something expected of you in the fierce competition for such a grant.

But we didn’t give up. I reshaped the team, narrowed the focus, brought in an experimental petrologist, and we tried again. We had only four weeks to turn this around from rejection to re-submittal. This next time we reached the interview in Brussels and were given ten minutes to pitch for ten million euros. A million euros per minute! We practiced intensely. The interview went well, but a month later we learned we didn’t get it. The reviews — ten this time — were mixed; some were very supportive whereas others were... harsh.

Still, we had another chance. After a day of cooling down, I told the team that it would be silly not to try again. Another four week sprint led to a further refined and focused proposal that built on the constructive feedback we received from the reviewers. We were granted another interview, and this one was very tough. We left the event feeling deflated.

A month later, we learned we had won!  The reviews were excellent. In hindsight, the committee likely saw us as strong contenders and wanted to test how well we worked together under pressure (ergo, the tough interview). Apparently, we passed the test.

What is the main goal of the project, and what does “synergy” mean in this context? 
To understand rocky exoplanets, I mentioned already that you must combine fields that rarely interact — each with its own vocabulary and culture – and fuse them into a coherent whole. You need people who can move between these scientific worlds of physics, chemistry, astronomy and geology.

Our project is a team effort that is based at three institutes: the Bavarian Geoinstitute (BGI) at the University of Bayreuth, the Earth Sciences Institute of Orléans (ISTO/CNRS) in France, and the LMU in Munich. The team is led by Prof. Stephen Mojzsis (BGI/University of Bayreuth), Prof. Kevin Heng (LMU), and Dr. Fabrice Gaillard (ISTO, Orléans). It is also important to mention that we have closely associated collaborators in Hungary, Denmark, United Kingdom, Italy and Canada.

The synergistic goal is that after six years, we will have a robust model linking stellar compositions to planetary compositions. This will allow us to predict what space telescopes should observe. And maybe — just maybe — nature will surprise us with something unexpected, even weird. As Arthur C. Clarke said, the most important words a scientist can utter are: “Well, that’s strange.”

How much do we actually know about the universe — and how much do we not?

We know almost nothing. That’s not an exaggeration. The universe existed long before us and will exist long after us. Our presence doesn’t matter to it — but that doesn’t mean we are insignificant. We yearn to understand the universe.

Yet, the universe is so complex that our brains may never fully grasp it. We will need help — from artificial intelligence or whatever comes next. We understand the basics of element formation because we can reproduce them in the laboratory. But we cannot travel back in time. We reconstruct history from clues — always ready to revise our story.

There are possibilities — types of planets, perhaps types of life — that will exceed our expectations, but ought to make sense in hindsight. This is the difference between looking and seeing.

Is there evidence for extraterrestrial life? And is there a chance that it exists?

Those are two different questions. The second one is easier: yes, there is definitely a chance. Life needs a stable environment, liquid water, organic molecules, and chemical disequilibria — essentially a planetary scale battery. These conditions exist on rocky planets throughout the universe.

Evidence for life outside of Earth? None. Zero. As far as we know, n = 1, and that value is confined soley to the life that we know.

How would you explain exoplanets to a curious non expert? Step outside on a clear and dark night and look up and allow your eyes to adjust. Be patient. The Moon glows because the Sun is illuminating it, even if the Sun itself has slipped below the horizon. Once your eyes adjust, the stars reveal themselves — thousands of them, scattered as points of light across the sky. It feels peaceful, familiar. But here is the astonishing truth: every single one of those stars has planets circling them. Every one.

We have documented nearly seven thousand exoplanets — “documented” meaning we have solid proof that they exist. But that number is misleadingly small. We only detect planets under very specific, favorable conditions. And whenever those conditions are met, planets appear. Hence, what we can detect misses most of what we cannot (yet) detect. Evidently, planet formation is the natural outcome of star formation: a star forms, and leftover material in the disk around it clumps together into planets. Planetary systems are not the exception — they are the rule.

And here comes the real surprise. Our own solar system — the one we grew up with, the one in every textbook — is actually a bit of an oddball. You might say that overall we have two kinds of planets: the small rocky ones close to the Sun, and the giant gaseous ones farther out. Two neat categories.

But we have learned relatively recently that the galaxy doesn’t work that way. Elsewhere, there exists a continuum of planets — from worlds smaller than Mercury to giants many times larger than Jupiter. And in between lies the most common types of planets in the universe: sub Neptunes and super Earths. These are planets larger than Earth but smaller than Neptune, and they dominate the exoplanet census.

Yet our solar system has none like them. Not a single one. It’s as if we walked into a forest expecting only oaks and pines, and suddenly discovered that most trees in the universe are birches — and we don’t have any.

That, to me, is the beauty of exoplanet science: it forces us to rethink everything we thought was typical. It shows us that our home system is just one quirky example in a vast cosmic diversity.

NASA’s Artemis missions are returning to the Moon. Are you interested in this? 
Artemis I and II are not primarily scientific missions — they are technological ones. We haven’t landed on the Moon since 1972. The institutional knowledge is gone. To return, we must train a new generation of thousands of engineers and scientists. That’s why these missions matter. It is encouraging to see us heading back in a direction we should never have abandoned. It is exciting that lunar exploration is not confined to the USA and NASA, with the programs of China and India also in the mix.

Does studying exoplanets also teach us about Earth’s formation? Ultimately, yes. But it also challenges the Copernican principle — the idea that Earth and our solar system are typical. They are not. As I mentioned to you just now, we lack entire classes of planets that are common elsewhere. Exoplanet science forces us to rethink our cosmic story — to develop a new mythology for understanding how special or ordinary we are.

Can you look at the universe without thinking about God? 
Knowing what I know is both a blessing and a curse. I can’t look at nature without analyzing it. My children ask what kind of rock something is, and I always answer. Their fortune is my misfortune — I sometimes miss the simple sense of beauty.

When I look at the universe, I see order and symmetry. Some attribute that to a deity, others to a simulation. I don’t know. But I do know that science cannot explain the love I feel for my family. That is not reducible to a formula. Interpret my answer whatever you will.

Can anyone truly grasp the idea of an endless universe? 
No. Our brains evolved to navigate three dimensional directions — left, right, forward, backwards, up and down. Even three dimensional thinking is hard and must be practiced. But the universe has no center, no edge, and expands everywhere all at once. Analogies like the surface of a balloon help, but they are crude and cannot capture higher dimensions for which we have no human experience of.

All matter and energy were once compressed into a space the size of this room — yet there was no “outside.” Time intervals in the early universe defy comprehension. Thinking about this too deeply can crush the mind. So we return to our campfires and tell stories as we have done together for millions of year — we compose our new mythologies — to make sense of what we see.

Do you think your field deserves more public attention? 
I think many people are already interested. If you ask about origins, curiosity is widespread. Not universal — but widespread. My goal is to reach those who are curious but unaware that this kind of research exists.

This field isn’t for everyone. You must first master something fundamental in the scientific enterprise — something you can model and test. Once you stand on firm ground in your research, you can explore. And if you lack a skill, you find talented collaborators. That is the beauty of European science — and the ERC Synergy program is its crown jewel.

What role does the University of Bayreuth play? 
The Bavarian Geoinstitute within the University of Bayreuth is what drew me here. It is a world leading center for experimental and theoretical studies of solid planets. The facilities and expertise here are essential for the success of this project.

What other questions are you currently exploring? 
Lately, I’ve been thinking a great deal about something that seems simple at first glance: the color of plants. If you take sunlight and break it into its spectrum, you find that the Sun’s peak energy output lies near the green part of light. And yet plants — the organisms that rely on sunlight more than anything else — are green. They reflect most of energy away. Isn’t that strange?

This question bothered me for years. It felt like a contradiction hiding in plain sight. So I started talking to quantum physicists and engineers — people who design solar cells and understand how light fluctuates. And they told me something fascinating: the green part of the solar spectrum where most of the energy is, is also incredibly noisy. Its intensity changes constantly, from dawn to dusk, from moment to moment as a leaf trembles in the wind. For a biological system, that kind of instability is disastrous. You can’t build reliable chemistry on a flickering power source.

And suddenly it made sense. Plants aren’t choosing green — they are avoiding it. They dump the noisy part of the spectrum as heat and harvest energy from the more stable regions on either side of this color. Nature has fine tuned photosynthesis not for maximum power, but for maximum reliability under the Sun that we have.

Once you see this, you can’t unsee it. The reflectance spectrum of plants — this global green signature — covers more than 70 percent of Earth’s surface. It is a planetary fingerprint, exquisitely adapted to our Sun.

So I asked myself: what would happen if the Sun were different? What if Earth orbited a more common star — like a cooler and smaller orange K dwarf? What color would plants be then?

The answer, according to our models, is yellow. The entire photosynthetic system would shift. The reflectance spectrum would change. And that means something extraordinary: we might be able to detect photosynthetic life on exoplanets simply by looking for the right color signature in refelected light.

We’ve modeled this for planets around nearby stars and proposed observational strategies for future telescopes. It’s one of the most exciting ideas I’ve worked on recently — because it connects something as familiar as a leaf with something as vast as the galaxy. This work is in manuscript form that is presently under review in a professional journal.

In our previous conversation, you spoke at length about how we can understand the conditions that make planets potentially habitable. Your new study narrows down the time window during which stable conditions for RNA may first have emerged on the early Earth. How does this finding change our picture of the very first steps toward life on our planet?

Our new work shows that the conditions suitable for the chemical ingredients for life: amino acids and proteins, nucleic acids and RNA/DNA, and cell membranes, can co-exist together on a clement surface of our planet much earlier than previously realized.

Your models suggest that until about 4.4 billion years ago, frequent asteroid and meteorite impacts repeatedly heated the young Earth’s surface zone. Does this imply that the emergence of life may depend more strongly on rare cosmic coincidences and narrow windows of opportunity than we previously thought?

More likely, the origin of life occurs in kinetic windows of opportunity when temperature, pH, water activity and the organic chemical building blocks can co-exist with enough time to react and increase in complexity. Our work shows that the opportunity for life to start begins 4.33 billion years ago and that already by 130 million years later the prebiotic milieux transformed into a living world with organisms not so difference from some of the simplest bacteria we find today. Earth was able to harbor this procreative environment, and apparently, opportunities for this emergence ran out on early Mars and other bodies of our Solar System. The only life we know is confined to here, to our home planet, Earth.

Geoastronomy

Geoastronomy is an emerging scientific field that links stellar chemistry with planetary composition. By analyzing the chemical signatures of stars, researchers can infer the building blocks of the planets that form around them. The ERC Synergy project led by Mojzsis, Heng, and Gaillard develops laboratory models, experimental melts, and atmospheric predictions to understand rocky exoplanets across the galaxy. 
Project homepage: https://geoastronomy.eu

ERC Synergy Grant

The ERC Synergy Grant is one of the most prestigious research awards in Europe. It supports small teams of outstanding researchers who combine complementary expertise to tackle ambitious scientific challenges. The geoastronomy project at Bayreuth, Orléans, and Munich is funded with 10 million euros over six years.

Profile: Prof. Stephen Mojzsis

Professor Dr. Stephen J. Mojzsis is a geologist and planetary scientist whose work focuses on the early Earth, the origins of planetary materials, and the chemical foundations of rocky planets in our galaxy. Before joining the University of Bayreuth, he held professorships in the United States and Europe and is internationally recognized for his contributions to geochemistry, cosmochemistry, and the study of ancient terrestrial rocks. At Bayreuth, he leads the geoastronomy component of the ERC Synergy project.